SCORM 1.2 vs SCORM 2004: Which Version to Export in 2026
7 min read Czytaj po polsku
Every authoring tool asks the same question at export: SCORM 1.2 or SCORM 2004? Our answer for 2026 is still the boring one. Export SCORM 1.2 unless you can name the 2004 feature you need. Here is what each version records, how LMSs really support them, and the bugs that appear when people switch without testing.
The short answer
Export SCORM 1.2 by default. Every SCORM-capable LMS handles it, and for a linear course with one quiz it records what most reports use: status, score, time and a bookmark.
Switch to SCORM 2004 4th edition when at least one of these is true:
- Reports need "completed" and "passed" as two separate facts.
- The course must save more than about 4 KB of state between sessions.
- You want question records with readable descriptions.
- One package holds several modules with prerequisites (sequencing).
One rule beats all of the above: if the LMS administrator names a version, export that one.
What the two versions are
Both are specifications from ADL, the US Advanced Distributed Learning initiative (ADL SCORM page). SCORM 1.2 dates from 2001. SCORM 2004 had four editions; the 4th, from 2009, is the one current tools export.
The mechanics are the same. A course is a ZIP with imsmanifest.xml at its root. The LMS opens the course in a browser and provides a JavaScript API object. The course calls functions on that object to read and write a data model. The names differ, so a package is always one version or the other:
| SCORM 1.2 | SCORM 2004 | |
|---|---|---|
| API object | API |
API_1484_11 |
| Start and end | LMSInitialize, LMSFinish |
Initialize, Terminate |
| Read and write | LMSGetValue, LMSSetValue |
GetValue, SetValue |
| Save | LMSCommit |
Commit |
For more background, the SCORM.com explainers are clear and accurate.
What each version records
SCORM 1.2 tracks one status, one score and a little saved state. SCORM 2004 splits the status in two, standardizes the score and gives the course far more room.
| SCORM 1.2 | SCORM 2004 4th edition | |
|---|---|---|
| Status | cmi.core.lesson_status (one field) |
cmi.completion_status + cmi.success_status |
| Score | cmi.core.score.raw (0–100 by convention) |
cmi.score.scaled (-1 to 1) plus raw, min, max |
| Pass mark in the manifest | adlcp:masteryscore (0–100) |
imsss:minNormalizedMeasure (0–1) |
| Bookmark | cmi.core.lesson_location, 255 characters |
cmi.location, 1,000 characters |
| Suspend data | cmi.suspend_data, 4,096 characters |
cmi.suspend_data, 64,000 characters |
| Session time | 0000:12:30.00 |
PT12M30S (ISO 8601) |
| Interactions | write-only | read and write, with description |
| Progress | none | cmi.progress_measure (0–1) |
| Sequencing | none | rules, rollup, navigation controls |
The weak point of 1.2 is the single status field. It holds one of passed, completed, failed, incomplete, browsed or not attempted. A learner who read every slide and then failed the quiz is completed or failed, never both. Most compliance reports only ask "passed or not", so this is usually fine.
In 2004, "completed and failed" is a valid state. Interactions can be read back and carry question text, and sequencing lets a multi-SCO package say "module 3 stays locked until module 2 is passed".
One detail people miss: 4,096 and 64,000 are the smallest maximums an LMS must support. Many store more. Don't count on it.
How LMSs support each version in 2026
SCORM 1.2 is the safe default because every SCORM-capable LMS implements it. Most commercial LMSs accept both versions, but "supports SCORM 2004" can mean anything from full sequencing to "runs a single-SCO package and stores the status".
Moodle is where many people meet this first. Its documentation has for years described SCORM 1.2 as supported and SCORM 2004 as only partly implemented, with sequencing and navigation missing. Simple 2004 packages often work, but check the docs for your Moodle version first.
The only test that counts is your own LMS. Upload a small package in both versions, complete it, fail it, leave halfway, resume, then read the report. Twenty minutes now saves a lot of support email later.
When SCORM 2004 is worth it
Completion and result must be separate. An auditor asks two questions: did everyone read the policy, and who passed the check? With 1.2 you lose one answer for every learner who failed.
The course carries a lot of state. A compact record of one answered question, like {"q":"q12","a":[2,4],"ok":1}, is about 30 characters. A hundred of them is 3,000 characters before scenario choices and visited slides. In 1.2 you are near the limit.
You want readable question reports. With cmi.interactions.n.description the LMS can show "Which sender address is suspicious?" instead of q12, if its report screens use the field.
Multi-module packages with rules. Prerequisites and remediation loops are what sequencing was built for. It is also where LMS implementations differ the most.
2004 is not worth it for a linear course with one quiz, for an LMS whose 2004 support you haven't tested, or for clients whose LMS you don't know.
Decision table
| Your situation | Export |
|---|---|
| You don't know the client's LMS | SCORM 1.2 |
| Linear course, one quiz, pass/fail is enough | SCORM 1.2 |
| The LMS is Moodle | SCORM 1.2 |
| Reports must show completed and passed separately | SCORM 2004 4th edition |
| Saved state may exceed 4 KB | SCORM 2004 4th edition |
| Several modules with prerequisites in one package | SCORM 2004 4th edition, tested in your LMS |
| No LMS, course goes on a website or intranet | Plain website ZIP (no tracking) |
| The LMS administrator named a version | That version |
Common pitfalls
Mastery score vs. the course's pass mark
This causes the most confused emails. The course passes learners at 70%. The manifest says 80. A learner scores 75 and the course shows "Passed". Many SCORM 1.2 LMSs compare cmi.core.score.raw with adlcp:masteryscore and record failed. In SCORM 2004 the rule is explicit: when cmi.scaled_passing_score is defined, the LMS sets cmi.success_status from cmi.score.scaled. Keep both values identical.
A related 2004 bug: sending 85 to cmi.score.scaled. The field expects 0.85. Anything above 1 is out of range (error 407), and no score arrives.
Resume that starts from the beginning
If the learner leaves early, the course must set cmi.core.exit (1.2) or cmi.exit (2004) to suspend. Otherwise many LMSs start a new attempt next time and drop the suspend data. On launch, the course reads cmi.core.entry or cmi.entry: resume means restore, ab-initio means start fresh.
A bookmark without the state
The bookmark only says where the learner was, such as slide-14. Answers and visited slides belong in cmi.suspend_data. A course that saves only the bookmark returns the learner to slide 14 with an empty quiz.
Suspend data overflow
Past 4,096 characters in 1.2, some LMSs reject the write and others cut it. Either way the state no longer parses and the course starts over.
The wrong time format
PT12M30S is invalid in SCORM 1.2 and 0000:12:30 is invalid in 2004. The LMS rejects it and total time stays at zero.
For a field-by-field view of reports, read What an LMS actually records from a SCORM course.
Test before you ship
SCORM Cloud offers a free trial account and logs every API call, which makes the problems above easy to spot. Then repeat the same checks in the LMS your learners use: complete, fail, leave halfway, resume, read the report.
How Scormbee handles versions
In Scormbee you pick the version when you export. The same course exports as SCORM 1.2, SCORM 2004 4th edition or a plain website ZIP, and the free plan includes all three. Every package you export opens again in Scormbee for editing, so when an LMS administrator asks for the other version six months later, you open the package, export again and send it. Starting from scratch? How to build a SCORM course in the browser covers the whole process.
Frequently asked questions
Is SCORM 1.2 outdated in 2026?
It is old (published in 2001) but not obsolete. It is still the most widely supported SCORM version, and for a linear course with a quiz it records what most organizations report on: status, score, time and a bookmark.
Can one SCORM package support both 1.2 and 2004?
No. A package declares one version in its imsmanifest.xml and talks to one API: API for SCORM 1.2, API_1484_11 for SCORM 2004. Export two packages and upload the one your LMS handles best.
Which SCORM 2004 edition should I choose?
The 4th edition from 2009, unless your LMS documentation says it supports only the 2nd or 3rd. The 4th edition raises the minimum suspend_data size from 4,000 to 64,000 characters.
Why does the LMS show failed when the course showed passed?
Usually the pass mark in the manifest (adlcp:masteryscore in SCORM 1.2, minNormalizedMeasure in SCORM 2004) differs from the pass mark inside the course, and the LMS recalculates the result from the score. Use the same value in both places.
Should I use xAPI or cmi5 instead of SCORM?
Only if your LMS or learning record store supports them and you need tracking SCORM cannot do, such as activity outside a browser course. For uploading a course to a typical LMS, SCORM is still the most compatible format.